Probably a 3.5 for overall. I would say a 3 for Dark Rival I, a 3.5 for Dark Rival II, and a 4 for the last one.Will post a more elaborate review in the future, but I didn't quite enjoy this volume as much as the previous 3. I think this volume didn't feel like 3 separate shorts, but rather 3 scenes if that makes sense. The first two each time they ended I kept thinking "wait, really? end it there?" but the last one felt a bit more singular. Still looking forward to the last.